Countertransference hatein the treatmentof suicidal patients. Here is why these concepts are a big deal and what you need to know. Winnicott, is a normal and understandable reaction of hate toward the patients personality and behaviors. May 21, 2018 in this way, countertransference is related to what occurs in transference, and one influences the other. The avoidant psychotherapy patient mdedge psychiatry.
The strength of winnicotts contribution was to constantly keep in mind the need to respect the antisocial tendency with firmness and compassion rather than to. Hate in the countertransference pubmed central pmc. This essay describes how the analyst aims to maintain objectivity in regard to all that the patient brings, a special case of this being the analysts need to be able to hate the patient objectively. Transference held by the medical section of the british psychological society, london, 25 november 1959. Pdf this paper focuses on the way political ideas infused the psychoanalytic treatment of mr. Humera quddoos explains why transference provides a rich and fertile field for therapeutic work.
The full text of this article is available as a pdf 1. I believe thatthetaskoftheanalyst callhima research analyst whoundertakes theanalysis ofapsychotic isseriously weighted bythis. Winnicott wrote extensively about the mother holding her baby, which he interpreted into the clientcounselor relationship. Winnicott recognized the impact of the therapists unresolved problems and suggested the analyst undergo analysis himself, to prevent damage to the patient winnicott, 1994. He did not write much about this, except to say that countertransference could interfere with. Donald winnicotts 1949 paper hate in the countertransference has come to occupy an important place in the psychoanalytic literature, both as a feisty critique of midtwentiethcentury biological psychiatry and as a brave statement about the burdens of. I believe that the task of the analyst call him a research analyst who undertakes the analysis of a. This paper is freely available online pdf and is not a difficult read.
Winnicott on hate in countertransference1947in analyzing psychotics, as oppose to neurotics, treatment is very stressful. J, age 35, is a married, unemployed musician who presents for outpatient treatment for panic attacks. The strength of admin july 9, 2019 july 9, 2019 no comments on hate in the countertransference winnicott pdf. Transference and countertransference can be understood using.
Countertransference can be broadly understood as past emotional reactions of the provider projected onto the present situation. Otherwise, when unconscious, countertransference may generate well rationalized but destructive acting out by the therapist. Although not usually part of the obvious language of cognitive behavioral therapy cbt, examination of the cognitions related to the therapist, is an integral part of cbt, especially in working with difficult patients. Donald woods winnicott frcp 7 april 1896 25 january 1971 was an english pediatrician and psychoanalyst who was especially influential in the field of object relations theory and developmental psychology. Winnicott hate in the countertransference tpo cambodia. Xv hate in the countertransference 1947 194 a xvi aggression in relation to. In the second part, we cover countertransference issues. Inhate in the countertransference, winnicott describes abroader form. An analyst has to display all the patienceand tolerance and reliability of a mother devoted to her. Transference and countertransference exploring your mind. Oct 07, 20 so as it turns out the famous analyst who stated that all analysts hate and fear their patients was donald winnicott. Indeed, winnicotts text on hate in the countertransference received only the most infrequent mentions. Winnicott in this paper i wish to examine one aspect of the whole subject of ambivalency, namely, hate in the counter transference. Winnicot, hate in the transference and transitional objects.
Winnicott on hate in countertransferencein analyzing psychotics, as oppose to neurotics, treatment is very stressful. Countertransference hateinthe treatmentofsuicidal patients john t. An overview of countertransference psychology today. The countertransference hatred feelings of malice and aversion that suicidal patients arouse in the psychotherapist is a major obstacle in treatment. Winnicott also wrote about the effect of mothers unconscious states, including her unconscious hatred of her baby, and he linked such hatred with the hate that those responsible for delinquents develop toward their charges and the idea of hate in the counter transference. Components of countertransference hate countertransferencehate,likeallhate, is a mixtureof aversion and malice. Winnicott noted in his seminal 1949 paper hate in the countertransference, a clinician might experience strong negative feelings as a result of being provoked by the patient. The countertransference hook is the hot button of the analyst that the client may find to get them hooked into the game. Counter transference an overview sciencedirect topics.
Pediatrician psychoanalyst hate in the countertransference. Countertransference phenomena will at times be the. Countertransference hate in the treatment of suicidal. A more usable winnicott 61 dimension of selfobject function that it deserves to be elaborated and given a primary role as a transference need.
He experienced his first panic attack at his oldest sons baptism 12 years ago, but does not know why it occurred at that moment. However, transference and countertransference can be the areas that cause the most significant issues for you as a clinician. The maturational processes and the facilitating environment. Countertransference an overview sciencedirect topics. Therefore, countertransference can be an obstacle if the analyst acts on it. The way that his anger became focused on my political activity had a profound. From 1945 onwards, post controversial discussions, winnicotts scientific papers forge a particular. Winnicott first described counter transference hate and cautioned physicians against ignoring the reaction. Hate in the countertransference oxford clinical psychology. Winnicott 1949, on the other hand, mainly spoke of objective countertransference as the analysts love and hate in reaction to the actual personality and behavior of the patient based on. Nothing in the new understanding alters of course the need for continuing awareness of the dangers in the narrow perspective of serious risks of unresolved countertransference difficulties being acted out within what is meant to be a therapeutic relationship. Indeed, winnicotts text on hate in the countertransference received only the most. Donald winnicott s 1949 paper hate in the counter transference has come to occupy an important place in the psychoanalytic literature, both as a feisty critique of midtwentiethcentury biological psychiatry and as a brave statement about the burdens of working psychotherapeutically with very ill patients. Hate in the countertransference winnicott pdf summary of d.
Freud hadoriginally understood countertransference asanobstacle topsychoanalytic work that wasbased ontheanalysts unconscious perception ofthepatient asafigure from theanalysts past. If countertransference hate is left unconscious, the therapy may adapt to the needs of the therapist, rather than the needs of the patient 4. Jan 27, 2017 humera quddoos explains why transference provides a rich and fertile field for therapeutic work. Hate in the countertransference on memory and desire. Countertransference reactions to a suicidal patient. So as it turns out the famous analyst who stated that all analysts hate and fear their patients was donald winnicott. Winnicott in this paper i wish to examine one aspect of the whole subject of ambivalency, namely, hate in the countertransference. In this paper i wish to examine one aspect of the whole subject of ambivalency, namely, hate in the counter transference. Countertransference is defined as redirection of a psychotherapist s feelings toward a client or, more generally, as a therapists emotional entanglement with a client.
Winnicott summary an analyst has to display all the patienceand tolerance and reliability of a mother devoted to her infant, has to. The concepts of holding and containing the client are a strong theme in psychodynamic counseling, following the revolutionary input of winnicott, bion, and klein. To define transference, start by thinking about the word transfer. This article is important in that it gives those dealing with psychotics a way of not acting out i. Born in plymouth, devon, england, to a prosperous middleclass methodist family. Countertransference is defined as an abbreviation for the totality of our responses to our workemotional, cognitive, and behavioralwhether prompted by our patients, by the dynamics incumbent to our helping relationships, or by our own inevitable life experiences. An analyst has to display all the patience and tolerance and reliability of a mother devoted to her infant, has to recognize the patients wishes as needs, has to put aside other interests in order to be available and to be punctual, and objective. Countertransference hate, a mixture of aversion and malice, may. Pdf on jan 1, 2017, claire cartwright and others published countertransference find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Inhate in the countertransference, winnicott describes abroader form ofcounter. Transference and the terapeuthic relationship working for or against it.
The counter transference hook is the hot button of the analyst that the client may find to get them hooked into the game. His contribution to the evolution of psychoanalysis constitutes a significant shift from classical freudian theory. An essential difference between analysis and other methods of therapy depends on whether or not interpretation of transference is an integral feature of technical procedure. An analyst has to display all the patience and tolerance and reliability of a mother devoted to her infant, has to recognize the patients wishes as needs, has to put aside other interests in order to be available and to be punctual, and objective, and has to seem to want to give what is really. In this way, countertransference is related to what occurs in transference, and one influences the other. The therapists repression, turning against himself. There is also a danger of the game escalating as the analyst becomes revolted by the transferred object, projects back hate and seeks to punish the client in some way. There are many situations where the analysts hate is justified, and in an ordinary analysis this. Hate in the countertransference should be compulsory reading for anyone involved with todays governmentsponsored talking cures cognitive behavioural therapy and the like. Nov 25, 2011 this paper focuses on the way political ideas infused the psychoanalytic treatment of mr.
Countertransference in child and adolescent psychiatrya. There are many situations where the analysts hate is justified, and in an ordinary analysis this can be managed and the hate remains latent. When you transfer something, you move it from one place to. An analyst has to display all the patience and tolerance and reliability of a mother devoted to her infant, has to recognize the patients wishes as needs, has to put aside other interests in order to be available and to be punctual, and objective, and has to seem to want to. Donald woods winnicott institute of psychoanalysis. Winnicott i nthispaper iwish toexamine oneaspect ofthe whole subject ofambivalency, namely, hate in thecounter transference. Winnicott i nthispaper iwish toexamine one aspect of the whole subject ofambivalency, namely, hate inthe countertransference. Presented in the second part of a symposium on counter. Hate in countertransference winnicott 1949 the beginnings.
Countertransference knowledge and substance abuse treatment. Winnicott, in his essay hate in the countertransference also recognized the. Buie, md,cambridge, mass thecountertransference hatred feelingsof malice and aversion that suicidal patients arouse in the psychotherapist is a major ob. Week 4 new trends and special topics in psychoanalytic theory oct. Hate in the countertransference donald woods winnicott. In treating patients with chronic suicidality, there has been a shift from. He may let his feelings towards the patient carry him away love, hate, rejection, anger, etc. Donald woods winnicott was a paediatrician who was amongst the first cohort to train as a psychoanalyst in the late 1920s. Here are some of the titles to whet your appetite primitive emotional development, hate in the countertransference, the development of the capacity for concern, fear of breakdown, and playing. Winnicott was addressing psychoanalysts who cannot bear the strain of acutely disturbed patients.
346 115 368 1085 542 513 295 75 912 422 271 856 1415 981 1329 228 382 55 1499 220 1275 902 1240 979 1067 622 1248 126 338 928 423 708 1413 148 956 418 172